Tamil Nadu NEET State Merit List MBBS & BDS Cut Off Marks Category Wise 2018

Tamil Nadu NEET State Merit List MBBS & BDS Cut Off Marks Category Wise 2017 & 2018: As now, CBSE has declared NEET UG Result 2018. All states will invite their state quota counselling registration form from 2nd week of June. Candidates who have qualified NEET 2018 are eligible to fill the online registration form.

Selection Committee, Directorate of Medical Education, Tamilnadu is the official Authority to conduct NEET State Quota counselling in Tamilnadu state. Out of 114602 candidates, only 45336 have qualified NEET 2018 exam.

Now the TN NEET State quota counselling will be conducted only for these candidates. Tamilnadu Medical authority will soon announce the complete state quota NEET UG counselling schedule on their official website. Candidates are advised to keep checking this page for more updates.

Tamil Nadu NEET State Merit List 2018

DME will definitely release the NEET cut-off 2018 Tamil Nadu for the own 85% state quota seats while DGHS, with respect to MCC, will release information on this cut off for its 15% All India quota seats.

The counselling jurisdiction will start the practice of entrance into Tamil Nadu MBBS by the next week of June 2018 tentatively.

Tamil Nadu NEET 2017 Cut-off

Previous Year Overall NEET Cutoff Category Wise:

Category/ QuotaMarks RangeQualifying PercentNo. of Appeared Candidates
Unreserved (General)685 – 14550th Percentile171329
OBC (Other Backward Class)678 – 11840th Percentile175226
SC (Scheduled Caste)595 – 11840th Percentile47183
ST (Scheduled Tribe)599 – 11840th Percentile15710
Unreserved (Physically Handicapped)474 – 13145th Percentile437
OBC (PH)510 – 11840th Percentile597
SC (Physical Handicap)415 – 11840th Percentile143
ST – PH339 – 11840th Percentile36

NEET Tamilnadu rank list 2018 pdf

Candidates that have scored the qualifying percentile from the NEET UG examination and have completed the Tamil Nadu MBBS application score will be qualified for the counselling around.

Tamil Nadu medical rank list 2018

Applicants that are the past to find Tamil Nadu NEET State Merit List through the counselling around is going to be contained from the Tamil Nadu cut-off of all NEET 2018. Candidates may check here for of the advice associated with NEET 2018 cut-off Tamil Nadu.

TN NEET Gen OBC SC ST PH Expected Cut-off Marks 2018

CategoryMarks Range
UR695 – 453
UR – PH449 – 324
SC453 – 324
SC – PH315 – 302
OBC453 – 450
OBC – PH322 – 312
ST451 – 288

Tamil Nadu medical cut off 2017-18

CategoryExpected Cutoff
General50%
General – PH45%
All Reserved Categories40%

tamilnadu neet cutoff 2018 quora

The booking Information of CBSE for its NEET 2018. The CBSE is going to possess the reservation criteria of 85 percent each their state degree admissions & staying 15 percent of their all India level admissions. Even the Tamil Nadu State gets got the exact same reservation criteria for its admissions.

neet cut off for Stanley medical college

The TN State NEET Cut-off 2018 will likely be published following the statement of this result. The candidates may assess their state quota cut marks off to acquire yourself a seat on your preferred faculty.

Tamil Nadu TN NEET Cut-off & merit list 2017 2018

tnhealth.org rank list 2018

The Tamil Nadu cut-off of all NEET 2018 should incorporate the scores and positions of those candidates who’re the past to acquire through Tamil Nadu NEET State Merit List. NEET aspirants can assess the NEET 2018 cut-off Tamil Nadu for finding an estimate of their possible scores to receive admission to a college of their own choice.

tn mbbs merit list 2018

The NEET cut-off Tamil Nadu ISIS founded on the issue amount of questions asked in NEET 2018 and also the variety of candidates looking for the exam, and might, for that reason, change to an annual basis.

neet Tamilnadu rank list 2018

The NEET Category Wise Cut-off will probably be announced following the statement of NET 2018 Impact. The cut-off is going to differ for every state. Even the CBSE board officials may announce the cutoff marks on the basis of the range of applicants by their state, total available seats in their state, the difficulty level of the assessment, previous year cut-off and also others.

TN Tamil Nadu NEET State Merit List 2018 – MBBS & BDS

Copy and paste the below link into your browser to get the Tamil Nadu NEET State Merit List 2018. Merit List for the year 2018 will be updated here after the result is announced and released by CBSE.

https://drive.google.com/file/d/0B8fY5tFZhFvfS2VNYktueUZjSWc/preview

https://drive.google.com/file/d/0B8fY5tFZhFvfMDNEdDVzRHVGSVk/preview>

The merit set of Tamil Nadu MBBS 2018 comprises names of those applicants that have scored the minimum necessary percentile from the NEET-UG exam and have completed the application procedure. The addition of titles at the Tamil Nadu NEET State Merit List 2018 signifies that the applicants are entitled to go to the counselling session of Tamil Nadu MBBS 2018.

mbbs cut off marks calculation

The merit set of Tamil Nadu MBBS 2018 will probably be earned in the diminishing sequence of this NEET UG score and also their state rankings of these candidates will probably be delegated appropriately. The Tamil Nadu MBBS 2018 should incorporate the candidates’ titles, category, admission number, NEET marks, state status and enrollment number. Candidates seeking entrance to Tamil Nadu MBBS 2018 admission may check here for of the important points associated with Tamil Nadu NEET State Merit List 2018.

Check Tamil Nadu NEET State Merit List 2018

The Tamil Nadu NEET State Merit List was announced for just those candidates who’ve qualifying marks in NEET 2018. In accordance with the NEET 2018 qualifying criteria, basic type applicants need to evaluate 50 percentile while booked course applicants need to evaluate 4-5 percentile.

neet toppers in Tamilnadu

The merit list may be the cornerstone of Tamil Nadu Medical Admission in 2018 to get 85% state quota seats while staying seats are earmarked for 15% All India Quota seats. In accordance with the Medical Council of India (MCI) statistics around 6000 MBBS and tens of thousands of BDS, seats are offered in government in addition to private health and dental colleges of Tamil Nadu.

 

Highlights of Tamil Nadu MBBS BDS Merit List 2018

  1. The merit set of Tamil Nadu MBBS 2018 will probably be published at the next week of June 2018.
  2. Tamil Nadu NEET State Merit List 2018 is likely to soon be jointly released for of the candidates that meet the criteria.
  3. The candidates won’t be separately informed about Tamil Nadu NEET State Merit List 2018.

Tie-Breaker Criteria of Tamil Nadu NEET State Merit List 2018

  • The different parameters employed by the government for tie-breaking from the Tamil Nadu NEET State Merit List MBBS BDS 2018 follow.
  • Nominees who have high marks in Biology from the NEET test get preference if there’s really a tie.
  • When the tie persists, then candidates with high marks in Chemistry area get preference at the Tamil Nadu NEET State Merit List 2018.
  • If there’s still a tie, then an offender old in age is advised.

Official Website: www.tnmedicalselection.org

 

NEET cutoff Tamil Nadu for the All India Quota in the year 2017 has been provided in the table below:

Government Medical Colleges

Name of College

AIQ Seats

15% All India Quota

UR

OBC

SC

ST

NEET Rank

NEET Marks

NEET Rank

NEET Marks

NEET Rank

NEET Marks

NEET Rank

NEET Marks

ESI-PGIMSR, ESI Hospital,K.K Nagar,Chennai

15

6,026

575

6,596

572

44,787

457

69,313

415

Kanya Kumari Government Medical College, Asaripallam

15

5,726

577

52,119

443

76,079

405

Rajah Muthiah Medical College, Annamalainagar

22

7,740

566

52,711

442

75,707

406

Coimbatore Medical College, Coimbatore

22

4,240

588

43,468

460

70,662

413

Government Dharmapuri Medical College, Dharmapuri

15

6,858

570

50,263

447

71,866

411

Government Vellore Medical College, Vellore

15

5,737

577

44,656

458

68,461

416

Theni Government Medical College, Theni

15

6,292

574

48,164

451

74,375

408

Thoothukudi Medical College, Thoothukudi

23

6,833

570

52,996

442

75,444

406

Mohan Kumaramangalam Medical College, Salem

15

5,457

579

51,298

445

74,806

407

K A P Viswanathan Government Medical College, Trichy

22

6,280

574

52,509

443

75,663

406

Tirunelveli Medical College,Tirunelveli

23

5,232

581

48,151

451

73,276

409

Thanjavur Medical College,Thanjavur

22

5,468

579

52,259

443

74,758

407

Stanley Medical College, Chennai

38

3,858

591

33,984

488

67,009

419

Madurai Medical College, Madurai

23

4,702

584

44,285

458

69,452

415

Kilpauk Medical College, Chennai

23

4,713

584

30,937

488

70,929

413

Madras Medical College, Chennai

37

2,417

605

13,835

539

59,798

430

Chengalpattu Medical College, Chengalpattu

15

6,055

575

39,233

469

71,586

412

Government Thiruvannamalai Medical College, Thiruvannamalai

15

7,596

566

52,960

442

76,167

405

Government Medical College & ESIC Hospital, Coimbatore, TamilNadu

15

5,416

579

5,702

578

48,452

450

74,260

408

Government Medical College, Pudukkottai, Tamil Nadu

21

7,252

568

51,701

444

74,746

407

Government Medical College, Omandurar

15

6,677

571

37,566

473

74,176

408

Government Villupuram Medical College, Villupuram

15

7,201

568

52,167

443

75,546

406

Thiruvarur Govt. Medical College, Thiruvarur

15

7,465

567

52,025

443

73,009

410

Government Sivagangai Medical College, Sivaganga

15

7,477

567

52,148

443

72,111

411

NEET cutoff Tamil Nadu for the State Quota in the year 2017 has been provided in the table below:

 

neet 2018 cut off for government colleges in Tamilnadu

GOVERNMENT MEDICAL COLLEGES

Name of College

State Quota

OC

BC

SC

ST

State Rank

NEET Marks

State Rank

NEET Marks

State Rank

NEET Marks

State Rank

NEET Marks

ESI-PGIMSR, ESI Hospital, KK Nagar, Chennai

1,115

374

2,030

321

7,455

206

11,828

171

Kanyakumari Medical College, Kanyakumari

931

390

1,838

330

6,827

213

10,816

178

Rajah Muthiah Medical College, Annamalainagar

2,669

296

8,804

193

12,291

168

Coimbatore Medical College, Coimbatore

566

428

793

402

3,800

264

4,549

248

Govt. Dharmapuri Medical College, Dharmapuri

951

388

1,822

331

6,124

222

8,998

192

Vellore Medical College, Vellore

949

389

1,433

351

4,960

240

7,453

206

Theni Medical College, Theni

1,617

340

6,401

218

6,530

217

Thoothukudi Medical College, Thoothukudi

939

389

1,931

326

6,987

211

11,735

171

Mohan Kumaramangalam Medical College, Salem

906

392

1,212

367

5,243

236

4,807

243

K.A.P. Viswanatham Govt. Medical College, Trichy

892

394

1,352

357

5,011

239

8,649

195

Tirunelveli Medical College, Tirunelveli

886

394

1,312

361

4,578

247

9,343

189

Thanjavur Medical College, Thanjavur

774

404

1,074

378

4,503

249

5,446

232

Stanley Medical College, Chennai

333

469

504

438

2,190

314

4,266

254

Madurai Medical College, Madurai

591

424

801

401

3,236

277

4,427

250

Kilpauk Medical College, Chennai

512

435

636

419

2,687

295

4,311

253

Madras Medical College, Chennai

130

524

289

477

1,407

353

3,627

268

Chengalpattu Medical College, Chengalpattu

684

413

1,193

369

3,812

263

7,233

209

Thiruvannamalai Medical College, Thiruvannamalai

2,078

319

6,592

216

8,036

200

Govt. Medical College & Esic Hospital , Coimbatore

984

385

1,651

339

6,989

211

7,930

201

Govt. Medical College & Hospital, Pudukottai

2,261

311

7,386

207

11,503

173

Govt. Medial College Omandurar Estate Chennai

759

405

1,006

384

3,575

269

7,012

211

Govt. Villupuram Medical College, Villupuram

956

388

1,939

326

5,867

226

8,027

200

Govt. Thiruvarur Medical College, Thiruvarur

2,122

317

6,654

215

10,277

181

Govt. Sivagangai Medical College, Sivagangai

2,173

315

7,029

211

9,348

189

List of MBBS & BDS College in Tamil Nadu for NEET 2018 Seats 

S.No.StateCollege NameUniversity NameTypeEstablishedSeats Available
1Tamil NaduKilpauk Medical College, ChennaiTamilnadu Dr MGR Medical University, ChennaiGovt.1960150
2Tamil NaduTheni Government Medical College, TheniTamilnadu Dr MGR Medical University, ChennaiGovt.2006100
3Tamil NaduMeenakshi Medical College and Research Institute, EnathurMeenakshi University (Deemed), ChennaiTrust2003150
4Tamil NaduStanley Medical College, ChennaiTamilnadu Dr MGR Medical University, ChennaiGovt.1838250
5Tamil NaduThiruvarur Govt. Medical College, ThiruvarurTamilnadu Dr MGR Medical University, ChennaiGovt.2010100
6Tamil NaduSRM Medical College Hospital & Research Centre, KancheepuramSRM Institute of Science & TechnologyTrust2005150
7Tamil NaduSree Mookambika Institute of Medical Sciences, KanyakumariTamilnadu Dr MGR Medical University, ChennaiTrust2006100
8Tamil NaduThanjavur Medical College, ThanjavurTamilnadu Dr MGR Medical University, ChennaiGovt.1959150
9Tamil NaduGovernment Vellore Medical College, VelloreTamilnadu MGR Medical University, ChennaiGovt.2005100
10Dril NaduTagore Medical College and Hospital, ChennaiTamilnadu Dr MGR Medical University, ChennaiTrust2010150
11Tamil NaduChristian Medical College, VelloreTamilnadu Dr MGR Medical University, ChennaiTrust1942100
12Tamil NaduSri Ramachandra Medical College & Research Institute, ChennaiSri Ramachandra University (Deemed), ChennaiTrust1985250
13Tamil NaduKanya Kumari Government Medical College, AsaripallamTamilnadu Dr MGR Medical University, ChennaiGovt.2003100
14Tamil NaduThoothukudi Medical College, ThoothukudiTamilnadu Dr MGR Medical University, ChennaiGovt.2000150
15Tamil NaduSri Muthukumaran Medical College, ChennaiTamilnadu Dr MGR Medical University, ChennaiTrust20100
16Tamil NaduSree Balaji Medical College and Hospital, ChennaiBharath University (Deemed), ChennaiTrust2003250
17Tamil NaduTirunelveli Medical College, TirunelveliTamilnadu Dr MGR Medical University, ChennaiGovt.1965150
18Tamil NaduMadras Medical College, ChennaiTamilnadu Dr MGR Medical University, ChennaiGovt.1835250
19Tamil NaduVelammal Medical College Hospital and Research Institute, MaduraiTamilnadu Dr MGR Medical University, ChennaiTrust2013150
20Tamil NaduVinayaka Missions Kirupananda Variyar Medical CollegeVinayaka Missions University (Deemed), SalemTrust1996100
21Tamil NaduChengalpattu Medical CollegeTamilnadu Dr MGR Medical University, ChennaiGovt.1965100
22Tamil NaduRajah Muthiah Medical College, AnnamalainagarAnnamalai UniversityGovt.1985150
23Tamil NaduKarpagam Faculty of Medical Sciences & Research, CoimbatoreTamilnadu Dr MGR Medical University, ChennaiTrust2012150
24Tamil NaduGovernment Medical College & ESIC Hospital, CoimbatoreTamilnadu Dr MGR Medical University, ChennaiGovt.2016100
25Tamil NaduGovernment Thiruvannamalai Medical College, ThiruvannamalaiTamilnadu Dr MGR Medical University, ChennaiGovt.2013100
26Tamil NaduDhanalakshmi Srinivasan Medical College and Hospital, PerambalurTamilnadu Dr MGR Medical University, ChennaiTrust2011150
27Tamil NaduMadha Medical College and Hospital, Thandalam, ChennaiTamilnadu Dr MGR Medical University, ChennaiTrust2011150
28Tamil NaduShri Satya Sai Medical College and Research Institute, KancheepuramSri Balaji Vidyapeeth (Deemed University), PondicherryTrust2008150
29Tamil NaduGovernment Sivagangai Medical College, SivagangaTamilnadu Dr MGR Medical University, ChennaiGovt.2012100
30Tamil NaduAnnaii Medical College, Pennalur, Kanchipuram (Rajalakshmi Medical College Hospital)Tamilnadu Dr MGR Medical University, ChennaiTrust2016150
31Tamil NaduKarpaga Vinayaga Institute of Medical Sciences, MaduranthagamTamilnadu Dr MGR Medical University, ChennaiTrust2009100
32Tamil NaduIRT Perundurai Medical College, PerunduraiTamilnadu Dr MGR Medical University, ChennaiGovt.199260
33Tamil NaduSaveetha Medical College and Hospital, KanchipuramSaveetha University (Deemed), ChennaiTrust2008150
34Tamil NaduGovernment Villupuram Medical College, VillupuramTamilnadu Dr MGR Medical University, ChennaiGovt.2010100
35Tamil NaduACS Medical College and Hospital, ChennaiDr. MGR Educational and Research Institute (Deemed University), ChennaiTrust2008150
36Tamil NaduAnnapoorna Medical College & Hospital, SalemTamilnadu Dr MGR Medical University, ChennaiTrust2011150
37Tamil NaduGovernment Dharmapuri Medical College, DharmapuriTamilnadu Dr MGR Medical University, ChennaiGovt.2008100
38Tamil NaduCoimbatore Medical College, CoimbatoreTamilnadu Dr MGR Medical University, ChennaiGovt.1966150
39Tamil NaduChennai Medical College Hospital and research centre, Irungalur, TrichyTamilnadu Dr MGR Medical University, ChennaiTrust2009150
40Tamil NaduPSG Institute of Medical Sciences, CoimbatoreTamilnadu Dr MGR Medical University, ChennaiTrust1985150
41Tamil NaduESI-PGIMSR, ESI Hospital, K.K Nagar, ChennaiTamilnadu Dr MGR Medical University, ChennaiGovt.2013100
42Tamil NaduK A P Viswanathan Government Medical College, TrichyTamilnadu Dr MGR Medical University, ChennaiGovt.1998150
43Tamil NaduMelmaruvathur Adiparasakthi Instt. Medical Sciences and ResearchTamilnadu Dr MGR Medical University, ChennaiTrust2008150
44Tamil NaduMadurai Medical College, MaduraiTamilnadu Dr MGR Medical University, ChennaiGovt.1954150
45Tamil NaduPonnaiyah Ramajayam Institute of Medical Sciences, Manama-NellurTamilnadu Dr MGR Medical University, ChennaiTrust2016150
46Tamil NaduGovernment Medical College, OmandurarTamilnadu Dr MGR Medical University, ChennaiGovt.2015100
47Tamil NaduMohan Kumaramangalam Medical College, SalemTamilnadu Dr MGR Medical University, ChennaiGovt.1986150
48Tamil NaduChettinad Hospital & Research Institute, KanchipuramChettinad Academy of Research and Education (Deemed University), ChettinadTrust2006150

Check other States NEET Counselling & Merit List Status

State / Union TerritoryNEET State Quota Counselling StatusState-wise Cut off & Merit List
Andaman & Nicobar IslandsAvailable SoonTo be released
Andhra PradeshDr. NTR University of Health and Science

Andhra Pradesh NEET Counselling 2018

Andhra Pradesh Merit List 2018
Arunachal PradeshDirectorate of Higher & Technical Education, ItanagarTo be released
AssamDirectorate of Medical Education, Assam

Assam NEET State Quota Counselling 2018

Assam NEET Merit List 2018
Bihar,Bihar Combined Entrance Competitive Examination Board

UGMAC Bihar NEET Counselling 2018

Bihar NEET Merit List 2018
ChandigarhDirectorate of Research and Medical Education, PunjabChandigarh NEET Merit List 2018
ChhattisgarhDirectorate of Medical Education, Raipur, ChhattisgarhChhattisgarh NEET Merit List 2018
DelhiFaculty of Medical Sciences (FMSC), the University of Delhi

Delhi NEET State Quota Counselling 2018

Delhi NEET Merit List 2018
GoaDirectorate of Technical Education, GoaTo be released
GujaratAdmission Committee for Professional Medical Educational Courses (ACPMEC)

Gujarat NEET State Quota Counselling 2018

Gujarat NEET Merit List 2018
HaryanaPT. B. D. Sharma University of Health Sciences, RohtakHaryana NEET Merit List 2018
Himachal PradeshHimachal Pradesh UniversityHimachal Pradesh NEET Merit List 2018
Jammu & KashmirJammu and Kashmir Board of Professional Entrance Examination (JKBOPEE)

Jammu & Kashmir NEET MBBS BDS Counselling 2018

J&K NEET Merit List 2018
Jharkhand,Jharkhand Combined Entrance Competitive Examination BoardJharkhand NEET Merit List 2018
Karnataka,Karnataka Examination Authority (KEA)

KAR Karnataka NEET State Quota Counselling 2018

Karnataka NEET Merit List 2018
KeralaCommissioner of Entrance Examination (CEE), Kerala

Kerala NEET State Quota Counselling 2018

KEAM NEET Merit List 2018
Madhya PradeshDirectorate of Medical Education

DME MP NEET State Quota Counselling 2018

Madhya Pradesh NEET Merit List 2018
MaharashtraDirectorate of Medical Education (DME), Maharashtra

DMER Maharashtra NEET State Quota Counselling 2018

Maharashtra NEET Merit List 2018
ManipurDirectorate of Health Science, Government of ManipurTo be released
MeghalayaDirectorate of Higher & Technical Education, MeghalayaTo be released
Odisha,Odisha Joint Entrance Examination Board

OJEE Odisha NEET Counselling 2018

Odisha NEET Merit List 2018
PuducherryCentralised Admission CommitteeTo be released
PunjabBaba Farid University of Health Sciences, Faridkot

Punjab NEET State Quota Counselling 2018

Punjab NEET Merit List 2018
Rajasthan,Rajasthan Medical Admission Board

Rajasthan NEET State Quota Counselling 2018

Rajasthan NEET Merit List 2018
SikkimState HRD MinistrySikkim NEET Merit List 2018
Tamil NaduSelection Committee, Directorate of Medical Education

Tamil Nadu NEET MBBS & BDS State Quota Counselling 2018

Tamilnadu NEET Merit List 2018
TelanganaKaloji Narayana Rao University of Health Sciences, Warangal

Telangana NEET State Quota Counselling 2018

Telangana NEET Merit List 2018
TripuraRIMS (Imphal), AGMC (Agartala), Regional Dental College (Guwahati) Tripura Medical College — Separate lists by each collegeTo be released
UttarakhandH.N.B Uttarakhand Medical Education University (HNBUMU), DehradunUttarakhand NEET Merit List 2018
Uttar PradeshDirectorate of Medical Education and Training, Uttar Pradesh

Uttar Pradesh NEET State Quota Counselling 2018

UP NEET Merit List 2018
West BengalWest Bengal Joint Entrance Examination Board

West Bengal NEET State Quota Counselling 2018

West Bengal NEET Merit List 2018

 

16 thoughts on “Tamil Nadu NEET State Merit List MBBS & BDS Cut Off Marks Category Wise 2018

  1. Hiii, sir i got 112 neet mark 2018 with 47 percentile i belong to bc community it is possbile to get in govt college in tamil nadu or other state please reply me as soon as possible and what is age limit to write for neet exam in next year for BC community

  2. HI , I AM YUVA, MY NEET MARKS 156 , CAN I GET GOVERNTMENT SEAT IN TAMILNADU STATE, OR SELF FINANCE COLLEGE

  3. hii sir/mam i got 123 neet mark 2018 with 51.52 persentile i belong to obc catagory it is possible to bds in govt collage in tamil nadu or any other state

  4. heello sir/mam i got 123 mark in neet 2018 it is possible to get govt collage in tamil nadu or any other state for bds please replay

  5. Sir / Mam I got 278 marks in neet 2018 and I belong to mbc category tamil nadu am I able to get seat in government medical college tamil nadu*tq in advance

  6. I GOT 200 IN NEET 2018. I BELONG TO OBC CATEGORY,IS IT POSSIBLE FOR ME TO GET INTO ANY GOVT COLLEGES IN ANY STATE? OR SHOULD I TRY IT IN ANY OF THE PRIVATE COLLEGES?

  7. I got 290 marks in neet 2018 and belong to MBC category.is it possible to get into any of the government colleges in tamilnadu plz reply sir/mam

  8. Sir I have scored 246 in NEET 2018, belong to sc category. I want to know if I could get a govt seat for MBBS in state quota in tamilnadu. Pls reply.

Leave a Comment